When is alone, even more lonely?

12 September 2018 - Elizabeth Nichols

Following the increased focus on the homeless crisis in the UK our third sector and chairty team give their views on a new initiative for homeless people which may overlook one of the most isolating aspects of rough sleeping.  

The recent government announcement that they intend to eliminate rough sleeping by 2027 is an objective which has been broadly welcomed. Coincidentally on the same day, a charity in Oxfordshire announced a pilot scheme to provide homeless people with laminated bar codes, which they can wear around their neck on a lanyard. The scheme is designed so that non-cash carrying donors can scan the bar codes using their mobile phones and make a digital donation. This innovative scheme is one which can be applauded, but at the same time one with which many poeple will feel slightly ill at ease.

Homelessness is a rising problem across the UK. According to latest government figures, 4751 people were sleeping rough on the streets of England in autumn 2017, a rise of 15% on 2016. Many argue that nobody should be homeless in a highly developed society such as our own. So, on the face of it a charity thinking outside the box to help generate funds for people who find themselves homeless is commendable.

So why do some poeople feel so uncomfortable about this new scheme? For some the idea of ‘scanning’ people diminishes the opportunity for social interaction – the one thing that so many homeless people report is missing from their everyday lives. As many poeple who work with homeless clients will testify to one of the biggest psychological barriers they have to overcome is the feeling of isolation.

For many people, being in crisis homeless gave them the feeling that they are somehow no longer part of society, to the point where they feel that passers-by treat them with disdain or worse still ignore them entirely. Those who find themselves without a home can often feel invisible to society, a dark shadow that nobody wants to acknowledge and human interaction can be as important to the well-being of a homeless person as the money they receive.

The innovative ways in which charities are looking to help support homeless people are without doubt both valuable and worthy, but could the act of reducing an individual to a ‘bar code’ in itself be a way of isolating people? Perhaps we are taking the scheme too literally, perhaps the lanyards will not be particularly visible but they will just be produced when someone stops by a homeless person, but there are many people who won't help but feel that the interaction could become similar to that of a self-service check out. There a temptation to wave your phone, scan a ticket and walk away feeling a sense of self-gratification, whilst denying that person the human interaction they so desperately need?

Society is crying out for charities who are prepared to break with convention and provide new and innovative ways to generate funds and help those in need and this should be supported. But perhaps as a society we should all consider, the next time we pass a homeless person in the street, that acknowledgment and respect for our fellow humans could be just as important as a financial donation.

Related news

Get in touch for forward-thinking, impartial advice

With offices in Bury St Edmunds, Cambridge, Colchester, Diss and Ipswich, we’re close enough for personal meetings with clients from anywhere across the East of England. Got something on your mind? We’ll be happy to listen and give you our thoughts.

Call us on 0330 058 6559
Email us at hello@scruttonbland.co.uk

Get in touch